We appreciate Dr. Carbonell’s attentive, expert, compassionate and level-headed medical care. Max always perks up as soon as we turn the corner onto Columbus Avenue, and pulls eagerly to go in. Once inside, he’s happy as a clam and always in a great mood for the walk home. In the three years we’ve been going to Gotham, I’ve never seen an unhappy animal in the waiting room. Fortunately we haven’t had a real crisis, but if we ever do we’re lucky to have Gotham.